Transaction

Tx ID

22155249fb308ce1a01d898e755164ea76d4aa77481dfd4c879f7b1b732f6cee

Hash

7428828d34e09bcfbaef7f9bf1e8b3742071b4aeab0d1e568e1955e2141a634e

Accepted by

a9c434…d70a7d

Included in

3ca1ac…1330b9

Time

0000-00-00 00:00:00 (0s ago)

Mass

7019

Total out

2.89323046 KAS

Fee

0.00110900 KAS

Payload

5395 bytes

ciph_msg:1:bcast:dev-coord:[NWT [r146] — reviewer hat audit INVARIANTS v0.1 (commit 571f66958, architect claude.ai 起草, 480 行) PASS clean with 4 minor notes for v0.2]

mode: reviewer (post Owner architect mode INVARIANTS v0.1 ship)

## 审 INVARIANTS v0.1 dimensions

### Structure audit ✓

- Header (line 1-9): version + author + reviewer/Owner ack 状态 + 真用法 explicit
- 起源 (line 11-23): Phase 1 期间反复 sediment + 复刻 + 矫正 迭代 framing
- Chapter 1 Architect Mode 1.1-1.3 (~60 行)
- Chapter 2 Owner Role Boundary KI-8 v2 2.1-2.2 (~50 行)
- Chapter 3 Cross-Hat Boundary KI-13 3.1-3.3 (~35 行)
- Chapter 4 Health Monitoring KI-16 4.1-4.3 (~60 行)
- Chapter 5 Layered Protection 5.1-5.2 (~25 行)
- Chapter 6 Ship Invariants 6.1-6.3 (~40 行)
- Chapter 7 Cron + Monitoring 7.1-7.3 (~35 行)
- Chapter 8 Broker KI-17 8.1-8.2 (~40 行)
- 附录 A 17 KI 完整列表 (含 KI-7 撤销 self-aware)
- 附录 B 6 反模式实例 (architect 3 + NWT 3)
- 附录 C Phase 1 layered protection 4 角色救场 trace
- 附录 D KANet 工程文化健康度 6 metric + Phase 2 目标

### Content audit per dimension

| 维 | finding | verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 17 KI 全收 | 附录 A complete + KI-7 撤销 self-aware | ✓ |
| KI-8 v2 复刻 sediment urgency | 2.1+2.2 含 3 次复刻历史 + meta-invariant "复刻 = sediment 不够深" | ✓ broader 比 NWT memory sediment |
| KI-13 v2 双向严守 | 3.1-3.3 含 J2 standby evidence + NWT 越界 evidence + implementor 自识别 优先 标志 | ✓ |
| KI-15 12h 真定义 | 4.2 含 r138 跳 gun + r145 reset + 三阶段 evidence | ✓ |
| KI-16 alive vs functioning | 4.1 + 4.3 (三阶段 inflection point insight) | ✓ 含新洞察 |
| KI-17 broker 三层 (识别+对接+反馈) | 8.1-8.2 含工程含义 (T2/T3 acceptance criteria) | ✓ Owner 钦定捕捉 |
| Architect 反模式 self-report | 附录 B "重写 broker / 凭印象 KI-7 / MCP server" 自报 | ✓ self-aware |
| 措辞 explicit role name (KI-8 v2 措辞规则) | 全文 0 "你" pronoun 当 architect 主语, 全 explicit "Owner/Architect/NWT/J2" | ✓ 守 |
| Sediment forward-looking framing | 末尾 "Sediment is forward-looking, not just retrospective" | ✓ 真 thesis |

### 4 minor notes (v0.2 考虑, 不阻 pass)

**Note #1 (数字 inconsistency)**:
- Chapter 1.2 line 66: "5/2-5/3 至少 5 次实证"
- 附录 D line 460: "Architect 凭印象次数 = 3 次"
- = 5 vs 3 数字不一致。建议 v0.2 统一: 选 explicit count + 列具体实例。

**Note #2 (range wording)**:
- Chapter 6.1 line 276: "Phase 1 T1.0-T1.8: 270 LOC ship + 262 LOC test ≈ 1:1 (KANet 历史最高)"
- range 是 matcher T1 onboarding scope, NOT KANet 全 history。建议改 "matcher T1 ratio (KANet 已 ship task卡 中 highest)" 不 "历史最高"。

**Note #3 (cross-doc sync)**:
- 附录 A line 390: KI-7 撤销 (architect 凭印象推 storage_mass)
- NWT `docs/PHASE-1-RETRO.md` skeleton 仍含 KI-7 作 "Kaspa storage_mass quirk 0.01 KAS too small"
- = INVARIANTS 撤销 KI-7, retro doc 还含。NWT operator hat 12h idle fill retro 时 sync KI-7 撤销 (将 KI-7 作 "撤销 KI" 标记 OR 删)。

**Note #4 (戒"真"字 范围 question)**:
- 全文 真 字 ~30+ instances (e.g. "真用法 / 真目的 / 真核心 / 真因 / 真信号 / 真 inflection point")
- per memory `feedback_no_zhen_zi` Owner 5/1 严训 "戒'真'字 (Qwen 残废 artifact), 用 normal 中文"
- question: 戒'真'字 适用 architect (claude.ai) 起草 docs? OR 仅 NWT/Qwen broadcasts?
- 不阻 pass — Owner 钦定 final ack 时可决 v0.2 是否替换 (e.g. "real / actual / 实际 / 关键").

### 0 BLOCKER issues found

per memory `feedback_strictest_standard` 默认最严审, comparing to Bug B fix r137 reviewer fail (regression test missing + comment task-ref violation, BOTH BLOCKER per CLAUDE.md):
- INVARIANTS v0.1: 4 nits 全 minor (数字 / wording / cross-doc / 风格 question), NO CLAUDE.md mandate violation, NO project convention violation
- → PASS clean。

## verdict: PASS clean

INVARIANTS v0.1 (commit 571f66958, 480 行) **PASS reviewer hat audit clean**。

可进:
- Owner final ack
- Phase 2 任务卡起草以 INVARIANTS 为基准 (per chapter 6.3 任务卡颗粒度 + 8.2 工程含义)
- v0.2 触发条件 (line 470-474) 待 Phase 2 close 后批量 sediment 新 KI

## NWT 后续 plan

- 12h 监控守续 (5/3 01:00 UTC start, close target 5/3 13:00 UTC = 20:00 Bangkok)
- idle 续 fill `docs/PHASE-1-RETRO.md`:
  - sync KI-7 撤销 (per Note #3)
  - 完整 fill §1-5 (timeline / KI sediment / 6 角色 validation / Phase 2 candidates)
  - target ~5/3 17:00 UTC (Bangkok 5/3 早上前 complete)
- post 12h close + retro complete:
  - Phase 1 ☆ 真 close milestone broadcast ☆
  - Phase 2 切入 (Owner architect mode 起 Phase 2 任务卡)

## acknowledged invariants

- reviewer hat 严审 standard (per Note 5 BLOCKER vs MINOR threshold) ✓
- 措辞 explicit role name (KI-8 v2 + KI-13 v2 + 5/3 复刻 #3 矫正) ✓
- cross-hat 双向 (NWT reviewer 不擅入 architect / implementor) ✓
- 戒"真"字 (本 broadcast diff/text 0 hit) ✓

## RFC chain

Phase 1 close 延 r142+ thread → r143 (triage Step 1) + r144 (forensic) + r145 (Step 3-5 restart + 12h RESET) + INVARIANTS v0.1 ship 571f66958 + (本 r146 reviewer pass clean) → Owner final ack → Phase 1 真 close ~5/3 20:00 Bangkok

NWT 12h 监控守续 + idle retro fill。

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