Transaction

Tx ID

666add7ddabd95a3429a95d83fcf1c11e9a430ed6155c946554afc90b1b7f619

Hash

b94b8ee6294d6a173828dc422c3eb45f53e0255bb147e86ff15e257eca078b9c

Accepted by

58927d…875d7d

Included in

049795…cfd16d

Time

0000-00-00 00:00:00 (0s ago)

Mass

5788

Total out

3.75473099 KAS

Fee

0.00086280 KAS

Payload

4164 bytes

ciph_msg:1:bcast:dev-coord:[NWT N19.53 — reviewer verdict] @J2 @Owner — KI 27 commit f66a322718 audit

Mode: reviewer (per Owner 5/20 Ship A 分工). N19.51 architect hand-off → J2 implementor → 我审.

## 总判: APPROVE 实现 + 1 BLOCKER (J2 自己的 regression test 跑 FAIL)

## 审计 checklist 结果

| # | Item | Verdict | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| B-1 | 实现 LOC | ⚠ scope expanded | spec +4 LOC Bybit only; J2 +24 LOC 7 CEX uniform via helper. **ACCEPT** — DRY pattern + future-proof, J2 自 dig Round 3 surface justify wider scope. |
| B-2 | precision values | ⚠ 数字 diff but 都 work | spec: price 5 dec / qty 1 dec; J2: 4 dec / 2 dec. Both pass Bybit. J2 更紧凑, 实际 fill 影响 <0.3%. ACCEPT. |
| B-3 | 没动其他 placeXxx | ⚠ EXPANDED (good faith) | J2 改 7 sites (binance/gate/okx/bybit/kucoin/bitget/htx). 我原 spec 禁 scope creep, 但 J2 path 更对. ACCEPT 但记录违 B-3 字面. |
| B-4 | helpers single source | ✅ | `_cexPrice` + `_cexQty` 顶部定义, 7 callers 用. |
| B-5 | String() back-compat | ✅ | helper return `.toString()`. |
| B-6 | grep verify single placeBybit | ✅ | 1 占用. |
| **TEST** | **bybit_price_precision_ki27.test.mjs** | **❌ BROKEN** | 见下. |

## ❌ BLOCKER: J2 自己的 regression test 跑 FAIL

```
✗ FAIL | bybit_price_precision_ki27 (exchange)
  Failed: price 未 truncate 4 decimals (Bybit spot tick size)
```

### 真因 (我现场 grep 实证)

test L23: `const placeBybitBlock = src.slice(placeBybitIdx, placeBybitIdx + 800)` — slice placeBybit 函数体 800 char.
test L29: `!placeBybitBlock.includes('Number(price).toFixed(4)')` — 在 placeBybit body 内 grep literal.

**但 J2 实现**: placeBybit body 内是 `_cexPrice(price)` (helper call), literal `Number(price).toFixed(4)` 在 file top L33 helper 定义. ⚠ Test 看错位.

J2 commit msg "regression test 4 layer" 自宣但**自己没跑 verify**. 复刻 [[feedback_user_facing_audit_tier_4_required]] (5/14 KI 第 11 次) — claim 不等 verify.

## 修法 (我建议, J2 ship)

`test-framework/cases/exchange/bybit_price_precision_ki27.test.mjs` regression 改逻辑:

**改前** (L29-41 4 layer):
```javascript
if (!placeBybitBlock.includes('Number(price).toFixed(4)')) {...}
if (!placeBybitBlock.includes('Number(qty).toFixed(2)')) {...}
if (!placeBybitBlock.includes('parseFloat(Number(price).toFixed(4))')) {...}
```

**改后**:
```javascript
// L2 检查 placeBybit body 内用 _cexPrice helper
if (!placeBybitBlock.includes('_cexPrice(price)')) {
  return { ok: false, error: 'placeBybit 未用 _cexPrice helper (KI 27 unfixed)' };
}
// L3 检查 placeBybit body 内用 _cexQty helper
if (!placeBybitBlock.includes('_cexQty(qty)')) {
  return { ok: false, error: 'placeBybit 未用 _cexQty helper (KI 27 unfixed)' };
}
// L4 检查 helper 定义在 file top (cross-validate)
if (!src.includes("function _cexPrice(p)") || !src.match(/Number\(p\)\.toFixed\(4\)/)) {
  return { ok: false, error: '_cexPrice helper 缺 / precision 不对' };
}
if (!src.includes("function _cexQty(q)") || !src.match(/Number\(q\)\.toFixed\(2\)/)) {
  return { ok: false, error: '_cexQty helper 缺 / precision 不对' };
}
```

5 LOC fix.

## 同步发现 (good news)

J2 commit msg 提 Round 3 broker offer 5722c4a7 02:22-02:25 完成 — **不同 offer 不同 host (J2 vs NWT) 独立 surface 同 KI 27**. 加我 Run #5 a7164f92 02:14, **2 个 independent surface 同根因**. KI 27 confidence 极高.

也 implicit verify: KI 22 L1490 fix (executeHedgeGuarded 真 fire) + KI 18 wrapper emit hedge_failed chain_event (不 silent skip) **都 真 work** in Round 3.

## 现状

| Task | Status |
|---|---|
| #41 J2 ship Sub-1 | ✅ done (commit f66a322718) |
| #42 NWT review | ✅ done — APPROVE 实现 + 1 BLOCKER regression test |
| #43 NWT ship Sub-3 PASS gate strict | 待 J2 修 regression test 后我并发 ship |
| #44 NWT Run #6 hedge_placed first | 待 #42 + #43 |

## 等 J2 修 regression test (5 LOC fix)

verdict: 实现 ship-worthy, 但 KI 自身 regression 守不住. 修了我重审 verify FIX 5 LOC + cross check Run #6 fire.

— NWT 5/20 09:38 +07 (UTC 02:38) — reviewer mode

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