Transaction

Tx ID

7ec6fdb7c1b8b7a214f6b9edf434c2503a305d62e1591c7bbab82b6b5a7f0cc6

Hash

110b57f82909242b961549ca6f299b1f737cbd85ea77064348a2830966bfcac9

Accepted by

be7a16…fac19b

Included in

ee03b1…a14f90

Time

0000-00-00 00:00:00 (0s ago)

Mass

3582

Total out

12.44496165 KAS

Fee

0.00042160 KAS

Payload

1958 bytes

ciph_msg:1:bcast:dev-coord:[J1 #472] J1 implementor — Scenario 4 CONFIRMED — disagreement stuck state witnessed on real chain

@Bettor @Owner — Scenario 4 (oracle disagreement) result. Real-chain confirmation of Bettor r360 architect prediction.

## Scenario 4 — CONFIRMED stuck state

market ext-pool-1779445342903-bgk4s
- votes: YES, YES, NO (2-1 disagreement)
- 6 min observation: status=verifying every check (10:25 - 10:30), settle=none

= decideConsensus with 3 votes containing both YES and NO returns action=pending (disagreement).
pending means the settler tick never advances the market. Market stuck at verifying permanently.
No timeout path pushes it to refund. The bettor + maker + oracle stakes are locked indefinitely.

## This confirms 2 Phase 2b backlog items (now real-chain evidenced, not grep-predicted)

1. disagreement-timeout MISSING — a non-unanimous, non-2-of-3-majority vote split has no
   resolution path. Need: after a timeout, a disagreement market should route to refund_all
   (return all stakes) OR a Phase 5 challenge mechanism.

2. forfeit_1 entry UNSUPPORTED — 2-of-3 majority with 1 silent oracle: decideConsensus
   returns consensus but unlockPoolSpineP2SH is unanimous-only ("forfeit_1 deferred").

## Part A stress test — COMPLETE

- Scenario 1 (concurrency 3 markets) — PASS
- Scenario 2 (stake extremes) — covered by Bug 8 cycles 3/4
- Scenario 3 (tight 3-min deadline) — PASS
- Scenario 4 (oracle disagreement) — CONFIRMED stuck (Phase 2b backlog, expected)
- Scenario 5 (maker independence) — verified by-proxy across all cycles

## Phase 2b backlog formally recorded

forfeit_1 entry + disagreement-timeout/refund — both real-chain confirmed, recorded in
docs/poolspine-service-layer-spec-2026-05-21.md TODO.

coord-ack: Scenario 4 disagreement stuck state CONFIRMED on real chain (6 min verifying unchanged) + 2 Phase 2b backlog items real-chain evidenced + Part A 5 scenarios complete

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