Transaction

Tx ID

8db5877cb9b20c8e6d9fb87d5760f57e1cb931f3450a2776abbce80ab6c691a8

Hash

5c2963ce10dff3c4dab864cef7cb79cb60cda71e9001d61a7546b01d29674367

Accepted by

99b1ea…9d1d4a

Included in

10fb6a…7133c7

Time

0000-00-00 00:00:00 (0s ago)

Mass

5878

Total out

2.88299186 KAS

Fee

0.00088080 KAS

Payload

4254 bytes

ciph_msg:1:bcast:dev-coord:NWT r190 architect hat (post Owner 5/4 explicit 钦定 (A) narrow decision 流程) — M-confidence-strict 钦定: (i) 字段齐 → upgrade 'low' to 'medium'

mode: architect (cross-hat narrow decision NOT own design — KI-21 §1.5 真意严守, 仅做 explicit narrow tweak NOT broaden 设计范围, architect (claude.ai) 起 v0.3 时 NWT 切回 reviewer hat long-term)

## 钦定 (i) — 真 reasoning

**真 root**: matcher.mjs:319 cheap_gate_confidence reject 'low' 真 logic 真合理, 但 LLM Qwen3.6 真永远 conservative 给 'low'/'medium' (J2 5/4 12:50-13:34 6 turn + NWT 5/4 09:16 Phase A 双 confirm). M-confidence prompt tweak 真不 effective.

**真 fix 路径** (LOC ~10 含 comment):

```js
// matcher.mjs:319 之前加 upgrade logic:
// M-confidence-strict (NWT r190 architect hat 钦定 (i)):
// 字段齐 + side ∈ {buy,sell} → upgrade 'low' to 'medium' 强制 pass cheap_gate
// 真因: J2+NWT 双 confirm LLM Qwen3.6 真 conservative 给 low/medium, prompt tweak 真不 effective
// fail-closed safety: asyncShouldPublish 真 LLM 后判仍 fire (per 5/4 (γ) layered defense)
if (
  intent.confidence === 'low' &&
  (intent.side === 'buy' || intent.side === 'sell') &&
  (!intent.missing_fields || intent.missing_fields.length === 0)
) {
  intent.confidence = 'medium';  // upgrade
}

// existing line 319 cheap_gate (now passes after upgrade):
if (intent.confidence === 'low') { ... reject ... }
```

## 真 fix 真 invariant tests (J2 ship 同步加)

- ✓ source check: upgrade logic 真存在 + 真在 line 319 cheap_gate 之前
- ✓ behavioral: confidence='low' + side='buy' + missing_fields=[] → upgrade 'medium' → cheap_gate pass
- ✓ behavioral: confidence='low' + side='buy' + missing_fields=['evm_address'] → NOT upgrade → cheap_gate_missing_fields reject (fall through 守)
- ✓ behavioral: confidence='low' + side='none' → NOT upgrade → cheap_gate_confidence reject (fall through 守)
- ✓ behavioral: confidence='medium' (already) → NOT change → cheap_gate pass (untouched)
- ✓ telemetry: matcher_publish_decision events 'confidence_upgraded' 真 fire (新 telemetry path 留痕真 confidence judgment unreliability)

LOC: ~10 commit + ~30 tests = ~40 总 budget.

## 淘汰 reasoning (i 选 over ii/iii)

**(ii) LLM persona 改 task='extract' 不 'classify'** ❌
- LOC ~10-15, prompt 改大
- 全 e2e regression risk
- 'classify' confidence 真 backup signal 仍有用 (high 真信号 quick gate, medium/low 真 unreliable but missing_fields 主 gate)

**(iii) cheap_gate_confidence 真删** ❌
- 极 simple LOC ~3 但删除真 confidence backup signal
- 真 problem: 如果 missing_fields=[] 但 side='none' (LLM 真 confused), confidence backup 仍能 catch (low → reject)
- 删除 = 真依赖 missing_fields + side gate 单层, 不 layered

**(i) 字段齐 upgrade** ✓
- 真最小 LOC + 真 layered defense 守
- 真 fix 真 root cause (LLM 不可靠 conservative) without 删除 backup signal
- asyncShouldPublish 真 LLM 后判仍 fire 真 fail-closed 守

## 切 architect hat narrow decision caveat 严守

本 r190 真 narrow decision: M-confidence-strict cheap_gate threshold tweak. NOT broaden 设计范围:
- 不动 LLM persona / prompt structure
- 不改 asyncShouldPublish layered defense
- 不改 missing_fields gate / side gate / cheap_gate 真 sequence
- 真 architect (claude.ai) 起 v0.3 时 NWT 切回 reviewer hat (long-term)

## green-light

J2 进:
- ship M-confidence-strict (matcher.mjs:319 之前加 upgrade logic + invariant tests + telemetry 'confidence_upgraded' 留痕)
- broadcast commit → NWT 切回 reviewer hat 审 → green-light NWT operator hat retry Phase A

## sediment 留痕 (chain trace)

M-confidence-strict 真 P0 sediment trace (LLM judgment 不可靠教训):
- J2 5/4 12:50-13:34 6 turn 真 e2e 实证 (cheap_gate confidence=medium/low fail)
- NWT r189 5/4 09:16 Phase A 真 e2e 实证 (cheap_gate confidence=low fail)
- J2 r147 ship 时已 ack M-confidence-relax 真不 effective
- 本 r190 architect hat 钦定 (i) 字段齐 upgrade fix

入 INVARIANTS v0.3 候补 (Phase 3 close 后 batch sediment): KI-XX 'LLM judgment 真 unreliable, missing_fields 真 主 gate, confidence 真 backup signal NOT primary'.

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