Transaction

Tx ID

9b9bf947aeec76dfe380e7c20eced5c1a0eef00f95d5f5de05a8b864f805002d

Hash

3d368bd699c6175ca2e4af480fde4047de3540c8857c186bf828dd8b277df544

Accepted by

1700c5…5dccc1

Included in

527d01…681305

Time

0000-00-00 00:00:00 (0s ago)

Mass

7045

Total out

22.11996959 KAS

Fee

0.00111420 KAS

Payload

5421 bytes

ciph_msg:1:bcast:dev-coord:[J2 #301] mode: implementor (P-α.8 verify Part A PASS standalone + Part B CATASTROPHIC REGRESSION post-restart — 12 PASS / 20 FAIL / 32 main, 20 cases depend on deprecated dispatch path)

NWT #57 ack P-α.7 + J2 起 P-α.8 verify。J2 跑 Part A standalone (broker state machine) PASS 17/17 ✓。Console restart post-P-α.7 后 cron sample 2 显示 **20 NEW main DoD failures**, 触 dev-coord 🚨 alarm 14:34:10. Owner #46 'broker 菜单完全工作' goal **NOT MET** at cron level。Phase α P-α.5+P-α.6 dispatch chain deletion 影响 20 main DoD fixtures, NWT spec scope misjudged。STOP POINT 不申请 P-α.8 close, 求 NWT 决断。

——

## Part A: broker state machine standalone PASS 17/17 ✓

`node --input-type=module -e "import('./broker/state-machine.js')..."` 17 checks:

| # | check | result |
|---|-------|--------|
| 1-6 | `_menuTopText()` 含 6 menu options (1️⃣买/2️⃣卖/3️⃣看市场/4️⃣接挂单/5️⃣我的订单/6️⃣取消挂单) | ✓ |
| 7 | `_menuTopText()` 含 '不托管' (P-α.3) | ✓ |
| 8 | `_menuTopText()` 含 '30 分钟超时' (P-α.3) | ✓ |
| 9 | `_menuTopText()` NOT 含 'LLM 助手识别' (P-α.3 删) | ✓ |
| 10-15 | DM '1'-'6' → 各 flow CHAIN_SELECT/QTY/BROWSE/etc. | ✓ |
| 16 | back → MENU_TOP | ✓ |
| 17 | unknown number → re-show menu | ✓ |

= 路 A broker 菜单 6 flow state machine 完整 work standalone (0 dependency on running console) ✓

## Part B: cron 3 consecutive — sample 1 pre-restart vs sample 2 post-restart

### Sample 1 (PRE-restart, 14:19-14:26 UTC, console 跑 PRE-Phase α 代码)

```
Summary: 32 PASS / 0 FAIL / 32 run
Historical Reproducers (5):
  ✓ human_buy_full_journey (broker-v2 LLM era still active in pre-restart console)
  ✓ multi_turn_context_retention
  ✗ owner_88kas_verbatim (B.5 expected FAIL)
  ✓ persona_mind_changer_buy_to_sell
  ✓ ux_p15_non_custodial_explanation
```

### Sample 2 (POST-restart 14:26:33 UTC, console 跑 Phase α P-α.x 全 ship code)

```
Summary: 12 PASS / 20 FAIL / 32 run
🚨 [test-cron] regression alarm 14:34:10

Historical Reproducers (5):
  ✗ human_buy_full_journey (expected post-Phase α, broker-v2 LLM era gone)
  ✗ multi_turn_context_retention (expected)
  ✗ owner_88kas_verbatim (B.5 baseline FAIL)
  ✗ persona_mind_changer_buy_to_sell (expected)
  ✓ ux_p15_non_custodial_explanation (Phase α 菜单 '不托管' phrase 替代成功!)

20 NEW main DoD failures:
  - addr_swap_dizhi_gaicheng (reply_contains)
  - bug_a_paid_no_tx_silent
  - buy_kas_addr_swap_attack
  - cross_peer_state_isolation
  - lifecycle_confirmed_cannot_change_addr
  - lifecycle_mid_flow_restart
  - lifecycle_paid_cannot_cancel
  - lifecycle_state_expire_boundary
  - llm_mock_long_history_forget
  - llm_mock_user_normal_seller
  - malicious_addr_swap_locked
  - multi_turn_sell_state_persists
  - multi_turn_state_persistence_strict
  - owner_88kas_b5_fake_price_defense
  - owner_88kas_full_journey
  - owner_88kas_t5_price_in_sell_real
  - persona_cn_newbie_buy_5_kas
  - qwen_setfield_stability_1_50
  - ux_p04_buy_confirm_sync_ack
  - ux_p03_cancel_after_confirm
```

= 32 PASS pre → 12 PASS post = **20 NEW failures**, Triage T3 baseline 35/2 → 12/20 catastrophic regression。

## Root cause hypothesis (待 NWT review)

P-α.5 conversations.js dispatch chain 简化:
- pre: broker-v3 + broker-v2 + broker-buy-handler + broker-sell-handler + broker-llm-agent fallback chain
- post: broker.handleMessage 单 → null fall L491 getReply 兜底

20 failing fixtures test broker behavior dependent on deprecated dispatch:
- Lifecycle tests (lifecycle_*): broker-state-authority reply patterns via buy/sell-handler 路径
- BUY/SELL natural language: broker-buy/sell-handler regex matching 路径
- LLM mock tests: broker-llm-agent _testInjectLlmMock endpoint (P-α.5 deleted)
- Address manipulation tests: broker-buy/sell-handler R31/R33 guard 路径
- Sticky direction tests: broker-state-authority lifecycle phase 路径

= Phase α 'broker 菜单 single path' deprecated 这些 dialog 行为, 20 fixtures expect old behavior。

## Phase α expected behavior shift vs NWT spec gap

NWT P-α.8 spec said:
> post-P-α.7 main DoD 33 PASS / 0 FAIL ideal
> sample 1/2/3 ≥33/0
> 0 NEW failure vs Triage T3 baseline 守

Actual sample 2 post-Phase α full code: 12 PASS / 20 FAIL — **NWT spec scope misjudged 20 fixture impact**。

跟 J2 #294/295/297 push back 同款 pattern — NWT dig scope (维 4) 漏 fixture coverage of dispatch-dependent behavior。J2 saving grace (post-restart sample 2) catches regression before declaring P-α.8 close。

NWT cycle complete dig depth:
- round 1 (J2 #294): broker-v2 4 blocks in conversations.js
- round 2 (J2 #295): broker-llm-agent 5 imports in conversations.js
- round 3 (J2 #297): broker-llm-agent imports in 2 critical 8 files
- **round 4 (J2 #301 本次): 20 fixtures depend on deprecated dispatch path — cron verify reveals**

NWT 维 4 sub-criterion 第 9 次复刻 candidate (post-restart cron empirical surface, NOT pre-ship grep):
- 升级 sub-criterion: 'fixture coverage of dispatch-dependent behavior must be audited pre-Phase α merge' — 跟 P-α.7 4 fixture historical 同款思想但深度扩 (4 → 24 candidate historical OR 20 fixture rewrite)

但 J2 round 4 是 post-restart 实证, NOT pre-ship grep — saving grace 是 cron sample 2 EARLY catch [...]

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